Benefit Goof Proof Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil Shade 1 — Non-Sharpen Tip, 12-Hour Wear

Benefit Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil is a non-sharpen tip brow pencil designed to quickly fill, shape and define natural-looking brows with a 12-hour waterproof formula.

Designed for everyday use, this compact pencil from Benefit combines a soft, angled non-sharpen tip with an integrated spoolie so you can draw, blend and groom brows in one tool. The formula delivers buildable pigment that lays down soft color rather than harsh lines, making it simple to create fuller-looking arches without fuss. Its waterproof, long-wear formula helps resist smudging through humidity and light perspiration, while the slim, travel-friendly design fits neatly in a makeup bag or purse.

How does the non-sharpen "goof-proof" tip make brow shaping faster?

The custom molded tip is angled and flat for precise strokes that mimic the appearance of hair. Because it doesn’t require sharpening, you get consistent, clean edges every time you use it—ideal for quick touch-ups. The shape helps beginners avoid overlining while still allowing controlled, hair-like application.

• Pre-shaped angled tip for natural hair-like strokes
• No sharpener needed—consistent edge each use
• Flat side fills broader areas; tip end creates fine lines

Will this pencil hold up during a long day or in humid conditions?

The pencil features a 12-hour waterproof formula that resists light moisture and smudging for extended wear. While it’s designed to stay put in everyday situations, removing it at the end of the day is straightforward with a proper makeup remover. Longevity can vary by skin type and activity, but the waterproof build improves staying power versus standard pencils.

• 12-hour wear claims for all-day definition
• Waterproof ingredients help prevent smearing
• Removes cleanly with oil-based or dual-phase removers

How do I achieve a natural-looking brow using this pencil?

Start with light, short strokes that follow your natural hair growth; use the spoolie to blend and soften any harsh lines. Build intensity gradually—two thin passes give a soft, full look while more strokes increase definition. The pencil lays down soft color, so it’s easy to layer without looking blocky.

• Use tip for hair-like strokes at the front of the brow
• Angle the flat side to fill mid-brow to tail areas
• Finish by brushing with the built-in spoolie to blend

What shades are available and how should I choose one?

The pencil comes in multiple shades to match light, medium, and dark brows; opt for a color slightly cooler or a shade lighter than your hair for the most natural outcome. If you’re between shades, choose the lighter option for daytime or the darker for more defined looks. Swatches can help determine the best match under natural light.

• Multiple shades accommodate a range of hair colors
• Choose slightly lighter for softness, darker for definition
• Test swatches in natural light for accurate match

Who this is for: The Benefit Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil is a practical pick for anyone who wants a quick, low-fuss way to create natural-looking, fuller brows—especially beginners, busy users seeking one-step application, and travelers who appreciate a compact, no-sharpen tool with built-in grooming. It’s also suitable for makeup lovers who want a waterproof option for longer wear without heavy, drawn-on effects.

• Packaging may vary.